27 January 2015

Critical Questions on Frankenstein - Please respond with a comment to this post by 9 am Tuesday, February 3


To get started on synthesizing your own thoughts on Frankenstein, and to prepare for discussion at our next two sessions, please select ONE of the questions below and in a paragraph, suggest how you would develop your response.
This does NOT require providing an answer to the question. Instead, consider what you find in the text that could indicate a direction, and what KIND of answer you find satisfying. Considering the questions within parentheses should help. For example, an answer that addresses what you know about Frankenstein's psychological character would be very different from one that sees the book as a philosophical statement. You might try free writing -- write about the question without pausing to remove pen from paper (or fingers from keys); don't allow yourself to stop, but transcribe what's going through your head until you feel you've run out of steam. 
This exercise is intended to prompt thinking about what you see as the ground of interpretation--what kind of response to a critical question seems to you like a relevant and satisfactory response?
You do NOT need to select the question you'll write on for February 10 now.

1) Why does Victor Frankenstein create his creature? (What do we learn from his own account—including things he does as well as says? What can we infer from what Walton, his teachers, his family and others say of him, and from what he reveals about himself? Do you understand his ambition more as a desire to extend knowledge, or as an unfulfilled personal need?)

2) Is the creature Frankenstein creates a human being? (What view do you think the author takes? Are there any characteristics or qualities definitive of humanity—according to the book’s view or your own? Is it important to consider how he differs from human beings? What does the Creature himself seem to think?)

3) Why does Frankenstein’s creature want a mate? Why does Frankenstein decide not to provide one? (What is the role of sex and reproduction in the story?  Are Frankenstein’s motivations clear and reasonable or obscure and suspect? What would happen if Frankenstein followed through? What wouldn’t happen?)


4) What is the source of the enmity between Frankenstein and his creation? (Why does Frankenstein abandon the creature? How does the creature respond? What lesson or principle does each of them infer from this? Is the book offering an allegory or lesson in this central conflict?)

13 January 2015

La Jetée: Critical Analysis and Formulating a Thesis - Post by 9 am Jan 20

GWU 47448 CAS 2010.11 Humanities II - Children of Frankenstein  - SP 2015



1) Prepare a one-paragraph statement that answers this question:

How does La Jetée convey a message about the impact of technology on humanity?


When you’ve completed the paragraph:

2) Summarize its point in a one-sentence thesis answering the question.

 3) Post the paragraph, followed by the thesis, to the blog, by Jan 21 at 9 am.

4) Read other people’s theses and be prepared to discuss them in class on Jan 21.

 

It will help to consider:

What is the story really about?

How does the plot present the story?

What role do science and technology play in the plot?

What makes this film unusual?

What do these unusual formal and stylistic features contribute?


Please do not consult any resources--criticism, reviews, fan pages, etc.--available online or in print before you write. Rely on your own analysis and ideas.


Course syllabus - Spring 2015 - Children of Frankenstein


GWU 47448 CAS 2010.11 Humanities II - Children of Frankenstein (3 cr) - SP 2015
Arts & Humanities, The Corcoran School of the Arts and Design                             Columbian College of Arts and Sciences
Tues  1:30-4:15 pm   Room 14A                                                                                                                                     Prof. Bernard Welt
Blog: http:// http://frankenpeople.blogspot.com/                                                                                      E-mail: bwelt@gwu.edu
                                                                                                                                            Office hours: Tues 4:30-6:00; Weds 11:00-1:00


The Humanities Course at the Corcoran is a required two-semester survey of works of literature, philosophy,
and social theory, and of the ideas that give them enduring value. The goal of this course is to provide thoughtful training in the methods of the humanities that you'll employ in all college work and in your personal investigation of ideas, books, and art:
§     close reading and interpreta­tion of texts
§     independent and collaborative research
§     exchange of ideas in discussion
§     persuasive critical writing.
As befits a college of art and design, we emphasize the development of innovative and original ideas and perspectives as much as rigor in academic research, reasoning, and presentation.

The two-semester Humanities sequence is intended to enhance students’ skills in:
§ Comparative historical study of world cultural traditions through examination of defining issues
§ Interpretation of texts according to genre, cultural context, and solid reasoning
§ Asking critical questions about texts and about the methods and assumptions of the humanities
§ Dialectical exchange of ideas in a collaborative learning community, cultivating a healthy practice of self- and peer-assessment
§ Development of arguments that test significant ideas and find support in meaningful evidence
§ Research enabled by library and internet resources
§ Writing with personal integrity according to the standards of contemporary academic discourse,  incorporating a process of prewriting, self-assessment, and revision
§ Analysis of contemporary media as historically evolving means for dissemination of ideas
§ The cultivation of personal values, perspective, and life goals through consideration of outstanding examples of thought and literature from other times and places

Our topic this semester is: Children of Frankenstein - Myth and Meme in Modern Culture. The rapid development of new industrial and post-industrial technologies is the pre-eminent characteristic of the modern era. It has transformed our essential relation to nature, to work, and to society and the state. As we are now said to inhabit a technosphere—bounded by our relation to technology rather than to nature—even our fundamental definitions of humanity have shifted, and we have re-imagined ourselves as robots, androids, and cyborgs.
                  Our central text, written by a young woman the age of most sophomore college students, embodies in narrative form the crucial idea that new technologies may one day overwhelm humanity entirely. Frankenstein’s monster, which has long since escaped from the boundaries of Mary Shelley’s novel to haunt the imagery and ideologies of modern culture, has proved a lasting and focal means for expressing concern about the limits of human knowledge and power. It’s in this sense that we explore the operation of the Frankenstein theme as both a myth—a powerful, popularly transmitted narrative condensation of a central problem for a culture—and a meme—a cultural unit that spreads and endures because it seems to help make some shared sense of our condition. But even this does not exhaust the possibilities of Frankenstein: feminist, psychoanalytic, and political readings, along with creative adaptations in a variety of media, show how enduring works can be refreshed reinterpreted in the attempt to understand changes in society and culture.

Objectives: Upon completion of this course, you should be prepared to:
§ Analyze a work of literature or film for both artistic strategies and historical and social content.
§ Respond to critical studies with a focused and cogent assessment of ideas and arguments.
§ Integrate your own original ideas and creative response into critical analysis based on sound examination of primary materials and research resources.
§ Use collaborative discussion, informal writing, essay composition, and oral/visual presentation to stimulate, refine, and convey your own ideas about artistic works and issues in the humanities.
§ Comprehend and explain the Frankenstein theme and the image of the artificial person as valid popular responses to the modern experience of technology.

Required texts (available by order through the GWU Bookstore at http://www.bkstr.com/georgewashingtonstore/shop/textbooks-and-course-materials under our course number):
Mary Shelley - Frankenstein - the 1831 version (Maurice Hindle, ed.; Penguin, 2003) ISBN: 9780141439471

Please be sure to use this edition. Others may not contain the same text; and we will all need to have the same edition so that we can quickly cite page numbers in class discussion.

All other readings listed on the schedule will be available online at the course Blackboard site, along with the syllabus, assignments, and other important and useful information. We will also use Blackboard to submit assignments, share resources, and send notices or comments to the whole group.
Readings should always be completed by the date stated on the syllabus. Because discussion will depend on specific reference to the text, you should have the required reading with you at every class session (in whatever format you choose: print or digital device). Group work may often depend on in-class analysis of the texts, so come prepared.
Films on the course schedule will be screened in class, and will be made available for download for review.
The Gelman library at GWU has print, video, and database resources that can enlarge your perspective on the topics discussed in this course. Consult the course bibliography for further reading.

The class blog at http://childrenoffrankenstein.blogspot.com will be where we post any supplementary materials (such as questions for discussion, images, websites, or video), and informal, ungraded but required responses to our topics, readings, and discussions. We’ll use blog responses to generate questions to pursue in class discussions. Please use the blog to notify the class of relevant resources you discover along the way, as I will do. Become an author at the blog by responding promptly to an invitation, after which you can create your own blog entries, including images and video.

Assignments:
Class discussion will often depend on your completion of a preparatory assignment in advance, so please keep things lively by analyzing assignments, asking questions if anything is unclear, and making your best effort to offer responses that reflect serious thought and your own perspective. All work must be submitted on deadline; just communicate with me in advance if you have a legitimate reason for requesting an extension.
If you must miss a session at which work is due, you must arrange for its submission by the due date, not after. Please submit work through Blackboard, and graded writing assignments as Word documents. Be sure to save your work to disk. Never leave it on a shared computer, or submit your only copy. If you want to propose alternatives to any assignments, it’s in your interest to submit them as early as possible.
You must use your gwu.edu email for all communications relating to the course, so be sure to check it frequently, or stream it into your personal email. If I haven’t acknowledged your emailed communication within 24 hours (including required essays), I haven’t received it. Do not wait to see me to inquire about work for this course; send an email to bwelt@gwu.edu 
Writing assignments for this course require you to read carefully and think independently. They should be thoroughly revised and proofread before submission. You may always opt to revise and resubmit written work within one week of receiving comments from me. You may be required to revise any written work that does not come up to a passing grade, with the consultation of tutors in the GWU Writing Center. 
Assignments are not optional; completion of all required work for the course is the minimum requirement for a passing grade. Aside from raising questions during class time, in-class writing and blogforum responses are the main way that you can set the agenda for learning in this course, so in-class writings and Discussion Board comments, though ungraded, may be mandatory to maintain good standing in the course.

Grades are based on evaluation of written and other work done for the course in response to our topics, objects of study, and discussions.
3 Critical Essays @ 20% each              =                60%
2 Shorter Essays @ 10% each             =                20%
Criticism Seminar                                                                                           =                10%
Pass/Fail Blog Responses                      =                10%


Required writing is evaluated on the basis of four criteria:
  • Observation & Accuracy (Good use of source: Correct on details, citation of evidence, inferences) 
  • Critical Thought, Originality & Integrity (Intellectual distinction, including Logic, Relevance, Significance, Fairness)
  • Coherence & Development (Completeness of Thought: Adequate development of thesis and points; Adequate transition showing relation of ideas, sentences, paragraphs) 
  • Clarity & Precision (Expression of ideas: Attention to exact meaning; Appropriate diction; Free of distracting errors of grammar and usage)

A = Excellent: unified, coherent, well-reasoned, articulate, developed, and original work
B = Very good: coherent and well-founded presentation, demonstrating critical thought
C = Competent fulfillment of assignments
D = Failure to address issues or argue coherently
F = Failure to complete work for course
You will receive an interim mid-term grade to indicate your standing in the course. Interim grades are not part of your academic record.

Course Policies (in accordance with GWU Policies):
Attendance: This course conforms to GWU policy on attendance, which holds that failure to attend class sessions regularly and punctually is grounds for failure in the course. Since participation in class discussion and activities is a major part of the course, late or irregular attendance will lower your grade. Arrangements can always be made to allow for religious holidays and personal circumstances.
Academic Integrity: The foundation for your essays for this course should be your own considered responses to our readings and films. Essay assignments for this course are intended to direct you to your own analysis and response to readings, discussions, and activities, and not to external research, or other people’s ideas. Information found online may be helpful for establishing context and background, but do not fall into the bad practice of substituting facts for ideas, or the opinions of others for your own. If you make use of any print or Internet sources whatsoever in preparing a presentation or writing a paper, you must cite them accurately and completely. If you inadvertently neglect to cite a source, your work will not be accepted until the error is corrected.
The GWU Code of Academic Integrity, which is followed in this class, states that “cheating of any kind, including misrepresenting one's own work, taking credit for the work of others without crediting them and without appropriate authorization, and the fabrication of information.” For the remainder of the code, see: http://www.gwu.edu/~ntegrity/code.html. Be aware that the Code may require outside evaluation of any instance of plagiarism.

Disability Services: GWU and the Corcoran support students with identified learning disabilities by providing accommodations and assistance. Speak to me early in the semester so we can discuss how to enhance your experience of the course. The GWU Disability Services Office can help you establish eligibility and recommend appropriate accommodations: http://gwired.gwu.edu/dss/; Marvin Center, Suite 242, or 202-994-8250. You may be able to receive assistance at the Corcoran through internal services.

Counseling Services: The University Counseling Center (UCC) at 202 994-5300 offers 24/7 assistance and referral to address students' personal, social, career, and study skills problems. Services for students include crisis and emergency mental health consultations, confidential assessment, counseling services, and referrals. See: http://counselingcenter.gwu.edu

Writing Center: Make an appointment online at http://writingprogram.gwu.edu/writing-center. Consult the Writing Center to talk over the planning of an essay I n advance, or discuss the process of revision.  You may always opt to revise and resubmit written work within one week of receiving comments from me, and you may be required to revise any written work that does not come up to a passing grade, with the consultation of tutors in the Writing Center. 

Cellphones should be turned off and put away during class sessions.  If you are discovered using a phone, tablet, or computer in class to do something other than work for this course, you are counted absent for the session.
Whenever possible, please leave bags and other impediments at the back of the room so we can all move around the space safely.
If you have any difficulty keeping up with reading or writing assignments, please don't hesitate to bring it up in class, in conference, or by e-mail. I will ask to see you in conference around mid-term, but you can always meet with me before and after that, too. My office hours are a good time to talk—by appointment, since I won’t always be in the office unless we arrange a meeting—but I’m available by appointment through the week.
I’m making some commitments, too: I commit to reviewing and evaluating your work for the course with serious and objective attention to the course’s goals, and to giving you feedback that you can use. I will focus more on developing meaningful educational experiences than on requiring you to prove your competence. I will not ask you to undertake work that I wouldn’t myself find meaningful and interesting. If you are not getting what you need from the course, I will listen to your suggestions and do my best to act on them. I will adjust the course work if it helps us meet our goals better, and I’ll keep you posted on any changes via Blackboard.


Syllabus, schedule and assignments are subject to revision according to the educational goals of the course and through consultation with participants.